People are mad at you, Strawberry Pop Tart.

When we received a year of the Wall Street Journal as a thoughtful gift for the year 2021, I never realized how much I would love looking for that italicized front page segment below the fold that includes some sort of fascinating human interest story. 

In late October, I sent a picture of the headline to Lindsay and said, “We have to talk about this on the TealHaus blog.” Not that we have an opinion on Pop Tarts or any sort of stake in the latest slate of odd court cases … but because it is a curiosity that made us wonder. It made us muse on the importance of accurate branding and honesty. 

Kellogg’s is currently being sued because the strawberry flavor of Pop-Tart, according to the Southern District of New York, contains more apples and pears than actual strawberry ingredients. They claim it is deceptive and misleading to label the pastry with the “strawberry” moniker and are asking for $5 million in relief. 

According to the lawyer filing the suit, Spencer Sheehan, “Nobody’s saying that you expected to get everything from a strawberry. You’re not eating a fresh strawberry, obviously. But if you’re going to call it strawberry, you either ought to have all strawberries in there or just call it something else.” 

So that brings us to a question: What offering does your business advertise that might be a stretch or could even be actually completely untrue? Is it a legacy offering you don’t have anymore? Or a gray area that sounds better when you leave it a little vague? 

If Mr. Sheehan finds out about it, he might be coming for you. 

Share This Article

You Might Also Like

The La Croix Phenomenon Revisited

Some of our favorite memes involve La Croix. One caption on an Instagram post back in 2019 or 2020 read, “It tastes like you were drinking carbonated water and someone yelled out the flavor from another room.” Yet, your refrigerator is probably full of some varietal of sparkling water at any given moment.

The Power of Imagination

For the first time, I got to experience the magic (and terror) of Halloween through my three-year-old’s eyes. Last year he really did not understand what was going on but was more than delighted to accept all of the free candy.

On the Saturday before Halloween, we were walking through Boo in the Zoo, admiring the larger-than-life giraffes when he urgently shouted, “Mama, hold you, a dragon!”

People are mad at you, Strawberry Pop Tart.

Kellogg’s is currently being sued because the strawberry flavor of Pop-Tart, according to the Southern District of New York, contains more apples and pears than actual strawberry ingredients. They claim it is deceptive and misleading to label the pastry with the “strawberry” moniker and are asking for $5 million in relief.